Image description: The shore of the River Eden, seen from Wetheral, Cumbria, England, UK.
Wetlands, buffer strips and cover crops could reduce nutrient pollution in rural rivers, according to modelling published by the Environment Agency on 9 November. The study also found that climate change is likely to reduce how well these measures work.
The research was commissioned by the Environment Agency’s Chief Scientist’s Group and carried out by JBA Consulting and Lancaster University. It used the CSF-HYPE hydrological model to test the measures in two mainly rural catchments, the Eden in Cumbria and the upper Thames. Nutrient pollution from diffuse sources such as agriculture remains a major barrier to good ecological status in many English river catchments, but little is known about how effective these measures are at catchment scale. The government has a legally binding target to cut nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment entering water from agriculture by at least 40% by the end of 2038, compared with 2018.
Larger cuts in the Eden
With all three measures in place, the model showed reductions over 2000 to 2019 of 22% in total phosphorus and 17% in total nitrogen in the Eden. In the upper Thames the reductions were smaller, at 5% for phosphorus and 8% for nitrogen. Reductions were greater further upstream, and the EA summary says targeting headwaters “can deliver proportionally greater benefits”.
The measures also performed differently through the year. Buffer strips and cover crops worked better in cooler, wetter months, while in-field wetlands were more effective in summer.
A smaller effect in a warmer climate
The researchers also modelled 2020 to 2040 and 2060 to 2080, using a high-emissions climate scenario. The EA concludes that climate change “is likely to reduce the effectiveness” of these measures in managing diffuse nutrient pollution. In-field wetlands, for example, reduced river concentrations of phosphorus and nitrogen by up to 3% and 4% respectively in 2060 to 2080, compared with up to 6% in 2020 to 2040.
Limits of the modelling
The EA is cautious about its findings. The results depend on uncertain input data, on the available evidence for how well these measures retain nutrients, and on how the model represents them. The model was checked against observed nutrient levels for 2000 to 2019. The effects of the measures themselves could not be validated, because suitable monitoring data are lacking.
The report concludes that effectiveness depends on design, location and management, and that nature-based solutions “should be used as part of a range of catchment interventions” rather than relied on alone.
Sources:
